The consumer organisation argued this was illegal because the authorisation did not involve explicit consent from the user. The German Federal Court of Justice asked for guidance from the EU's highest court to rule on the case in relation to EU laws on internet privacy. The EU court sided with the German consumer group, saying EU law aimed to protect consumers from interference with their private lives.
The Norwegian Research Centre for Computers and Law at the University of Oslo said in a statement that the ruling is "likely to have a significant impact on the ongoing negotiations on the ePrivacy regulation which is set to regulate cookie usage."