However, the industry maintains that the recent decision of Punjab government conveyed through a letter to federal government to bring exports of sugar to a halt is impulsive and not based on reality. The permission was granted to sugar industry at the beginning of crushing season to facilitate disposal of surplus sugar. So far contracts for 209,693 tons have been made against 1.1 million tons quota.
The prime objective was to stabilize the price of sugar which has been reeling in the past and resultantly payments to sugarcane growers have not been forthcoming. The government with a view to ensuring payments to farmers supported the demand of the industry in view of the carry-over. Punjab allowed subsidy of 5.35/kg subject to a cap of three billion tons. This implied that for every 1.1 million tons of sugar, mills of Punjab would be eligible to export about 560,000 tons of sugar but unfortunately to the dismay of sugar industry an abrupt discontinuation of exports that is adversely affecting payments to sugarcane growers.
"Punjab government has unleashed district administration against the sugar industry without realizing that the remaining payments can only be made once the sale of sugar takes place during the off season," said one the stakeholders, adding that the provincial government is trying to enforce/invoke the rule under the cane act 1950 to clear payments to sugarcane growers in 15 days. This rule was made when government of Pakistan would buy the entire quantity of sugar and mills had enough liquidity to pay to the growers outright or within 15 days. Now that coercive action is being taken in Punjab by sealing the godowns the mills seek to get redressal from the Buzdar government to allow them a reasonable time to clear the remaining dues of the growers', primarily for the last 15 day payment for purchases at 230-240 level but to no avail. Sugar mills are able to make payments during the season by partially selling and partially availing the finances against pledge of sugar and the cycle continues till the close of season.
Sugar industry claims that currently a drive has been initiated against it as on the one hand they do not have the window to export and on the other industry is being asked to clear the dues outright despite the fact that the sale price is still not commensurate with the cost of production.
Supreme Court of Pakistan took suo motu notice of non-payment of growers' dues last year on 24th April and gave the industry five weeks which were later extended to seven weeks and by mid June a large quantum of payments were cleared and the case adjourned until January 2019. It establishes the fact that the apex court allowed a decent time in view of the peculiar situation faced by the industry after the close of crushing season as production takes place in four months and sale continues for twelve months.
During the current crushing season due to paucity of sugarcane, mills ended up paying 235/240 per 40/kg which gives an additional margin of about Rs.50/40 kg to growers. For buying and selling of commodities in the open market the time frame is normally 45/60/90 days for payment.
"It is now high time to de-regulate the sugar sector and let the system be driven by market forces based on survival of the fittest and government should disassociate itself from micro managing to enhance overall productivity in the country," said the stakeholder.
An official stated that since the sugar export decision was taken by the ECC, any review of the decision is also the domain of the same forum not the Commerce Division.