The Institute of Architects Pakistan - Karachi Chapter organized the conference at a hotel under the sponsorship by TPL Properties. At a panel discussion, which CEO of Dawn Media Group Hameed Haroon moderated, architecture experts namely Arif Hassan, chairman of Orangi Pilot Project- Research & Training Institute, Henry Squire, partner at Squire & Partners - a third generation Architectural Practice in London and Hamish Brown said that planners should design new developments but heritage should remain their source of inspiration.
They said that infrastructure development should go on to facilitate the public with growing civic and commuting needs in the metropolis but this should be done without defacing or destroying the old structures. They said that the architects may create a new heritage for future if the city has remnants from past.
They said that planners can learn from the buildings developed in the past. They said that the attention towards old structure is required for their preservations. They expressed concerns over the new high-rise buildings that are developed with a poor quality of architecture.
In the context of Karachi, they believed that the heritage buildings cannot be rehabilitated to their old designs but with some structural changes. However, they said that the infrastructure development has become a basic need for human globally but that also poses a threat to old buildings.
They said that infrastructure is crucial for cities but protection of heritage from their negative impacts should also be kept in view. They observed that the conflict between infrastructure development and heritage will continue. They said that the environmental degradation and collapse of utilities caused decay to the heritage structure in the metropolis.
They said that the heritage needs a favourable environment for its preservation and public and governments need to be sensitized to sense the significance of the historic constructions. Earlier, Henry Squire gave his presentation on 'Heritage - International Context' in which cited rehabilitation of London's old structures.
He said that preservation of old buildings should also reflect past of the heritage and should be done with a temporary treatment without changing their facets. Amir Chaudhry, chairman of Institute of Architects Pakistan (IAP), in his welcome note, said that Karachi has been on the brink of disaster because it was neglected since long and it has been growing rapidly but without any direction.
"There is a need to initiate dialogue and learn from peers all over the world in order to contribute to the urgent task to make this city better," he said, adding that Karachi was developed as a transit gateway towards Central Asia.
He said that people are now more concerned with necessities rather than heritage. He said that real estate development threatens historic and natural environment. He was of the view that there is low priority for heritage in our agenda and budget. "Although the situation is despairing but everything is not lost. We need to keep documenting heritage sites," said Amir Chaudhry.
The second panel discussion was on 'Heritage - Karachi Context.' The session was moderated by Tariq Hasan and panelists included Dr. Noman Ahmed, Dr. Kaleemullah Lashari, AR Fazal Noor and Agha Maqsood Abbas, DG SBCA.
They said that economic viability of heritage sites is very crucial. Bigger question is how to reuse the heritage buildings. DG SBCA, Agha Maqsood was of the opinion that controversies between successive provincial and local governments resulted in delay of projects.
He emphasized that new strategic and master plan for city is very crucial for development and preservation. "The listing criteria for heritage buildings have been finalized only three years ago but should be revisited and opinion of all stakeholders should be sought on how to preserve and conserve the city's heritage," he proposed.
The third panel discussion was based on 'Prevailing laws for Heritage Buildings and Districts.' Moderated by Ramiz Baig, panel included Arif Hasan, Dr. Noman Ahmed, Marvi Mazhar and Haider Waheed. The speakers highlighted the rigidity of laws and lack of stakeholders' involvement during the process. They said that there should be more flexibility and choices when it comes to laws of preservation. They also emphasized on the need to motivate people for preservation of heritage buildings. They said that steps such as relaxation in property taxes may also be taken.
Dr. Noman Ahmed of Department of Architecture and Planning at the NED University said that heritage cell was working in NED's architecture department with an aim to facilitate preservation and conservation initiatives.
"In 2005, listing of heritage building in Karachi was completed, resulting in preservation of many historical and heritage sites," he said. Karachi Mayor Waseem Akhter said that architects play key role in preservation of heritage. He stressed on the need to address the issue urban recognition and suitability of heritage and challenges associated with it.
"We are undertaking thorough process to harmonize efforts of preservation. The state has limited resources hence public-private partnership may play a pivotal role," he said.
On the occasion, TPL Properties announced 'Jameel Yusuf Heritage Award' of Rs 100,000 to motivate youth and recognize efforts of young architects in Pakistan. The award will be bestowed annually upon a young architect with an outstanding contribution to the field of heritage.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2017