This was the crux of a briefing given by the Chief Executive Officer (CEO), SECMC Shamsuddin Ahmed Shaikh, to Islamabad- based journalists in an open air project site at Thar. Government of Sindh, M/s Engro and House of Habib are the key stakeholders of the project.
He gave a detailed presentation on the project along with phase- wise progress besides hardships being faced by the management despite the fact that three top political parties ie PML (N), PPP and PTI are supporting it. He said, Chinese banks ie ICBC, Bank of China and China Development maintain that in addition to GoP sovereign guarantee, Sinosure should also give loan's repayment guarantee.
"Chinese banks want that 50 percent risk should be accepted by Engro and 50 percent by SinoSure and insist that they cannot take the risk," he said, hoping that the issue would be resolved during the visit of Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif to China scheduled for the first week of next month. He further maintained that 80 percent risk should be taken by Sinosure and 20 percent by Chinese banks. The country would save $1.2 billion per annum compared to producing electricity from furnace oil.
He said when there is political instability, no one will come to invest in that country and Pakistan is facing instability. "Thar coal project has been put in early harvest projects to be implemented with Chinese co-operation despite that Chinese banks' including Exim, China Development Bank and ICBC are reluctant to extend loan and the project has been placed in high risk area," he added.
He also maintained that the regulator had capped upfront Sinosure fee at 7 percent, however, due to the prevalent circular debt situation in Pakistan, Sinosure is asking a fee of 9 percent for credit risk insurance. "Therefore, Sinosure fee cap needs to be aligned with the market rate," he added.
"Thar coal project can not be implemented unless financing issues with China are settled," he said adding that China was the only country which had agreed to extend financing as no other country has shown any willingness. He further stated that SECMC would invest $2.2 billion - $0.9 billion for coal mining and $1.1 billion for power plant. He said that Chinese banks were to extend $560 million.
He said that Engro had already raised funds from local banks against a sovereign guarantee. In reply to a question, he said that M/s Engro is not in a position to take commercial risk. "We have no issue of financing for the coal mining project as local banks and firms have agreed to extend financing but the issue is financing from China to set up Thar coal-based power plant project," he said adding that National Electric Power Regulatory Authority (Nepra) had allowed a spread of 4.5 percent over Libor rate. However, Chinese banks did not accept it and demanded 5.5 percent. "The Authority has allowed a spread of 4.5 percent over Libor rate. GoP, on the other hand, recently issued dollar bonds for five and ten years at pricing of 7.5 percent and 8.25 percent respectively. Thus Nepra's proposed rate of financing is extremely low for a project with a tenor of 14 years containing all sorts of project and commercial risks in addition to high country risk of Pakistan," Shaikh continued.
He further stated that currently Nepra has allowed one Commercial Operation Date (COD) for a complex of two power plants but the second power plant will become operational four months after the first one. He suggested that the Authority should allow two CODs as it will allow the first power plant to start providing power to the grid instead of remaining idle for four months.
CEO, SECMC rejected the minimum plant availability approved by Nepra, saying that the Authority revised the condition from 82 percent to 85 percent. He added that the value of 85 percent is impractical for the first two years. He said that they were facing problems at domestic level as Economic Co-ordination Committee (ECC) had approved a package to treat this project on IPP model but no SRO had been issued so far.
"Four vehicles for project are stuck at Karachi airport for nearly two months and Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) is not clearing those vehicles," he added. He said that contract had been awarded to local contractor to exploit reserves of Thar coal and one percent work had been completed so far.
"Government of Sindh has allotted 3000 acres of land for Thar coal project where SECMC has purchased 3000 acres from private people at Rs 180,000 per acre," he added. However, the chieftain of one of the village that needs to be resettled has expressed unhappiness at the price of land given to the land owners. He said, they had sought Rs 0.5 million for each acre. Fayyaz Soomro Manager land acquisition, SECMC told Business Recorder that land owners have been paid the best possible price for their land in consultation with district management. He said the Sindh government has not approved resettlement policy.
Shamsuddin Shaikh revealed that the Sindh government has been requested to waive off royalty till the time coal prices are at international level. He maintained SECMC is negotiating royalty between 2 percent and 5 percent with the Sindh government. Engro's equity is $260 million in the project and one percent of work has been completed on the project.
He said that current installed capacity was 20213 Megawatt (MW) and local requirement would increase to 113,695 MW by 2030 with 35 percent rise in demand every year. "In India, 70 percent electricity comes from coal and Pakistan is the 7th largest country with coal reserves," he said adding that the best option for Pakistan is also to generate electricity from coal," he said.
Shamsuddin Shaikh complained that Thar coal power project has not enjoyed the benefits of the Economic Corridor. He further stated that Thar coal project has not been given coal tariff so far and until this issue is resolved, Nepra's tariff will remain controversial. In reply to a question, he said, Thar coal power project will achieve financial close during the first quarter of next year.