In his version of the actual event of January 27, 2011, Raymond Davis is clearly stretching the truth by justifying his act of killing as being 'self-defense'. Before she died on Feb 6 the widow of one of the victims who swallowed rat poison in Faisalabad told the doctors of being forced to accept Diyyat (a form of monetary compensation or blood money). After the families of the men killed were paid $2.4 million in Diyyat on March 16, the judge acquitted Davis and he left Pakistan.
Davis alleges that other than John Kerry, Nawaz Sharif, Asif Zardari, the then ISI chief General Ahmed Shuja Pasha and Hussain Haqqani, the Army and the ISI orchestrated his speedy release. The common perception given by the Davis narrative is that the Pakistan intelligence was responsible for Davis' acquittal and return to the US and that it was not an arrangement between the Pakistan and the US governments. This is patently false.
First claimed as a diplomat, then a consular employee Davis later "became" a civilian on a business visa. Among the items recovered from Davis' car was a camera containing photographs of Pakistani military installations, obviously taken surreptitiously. President Obama commented on Feb 15, "Davis, our diplomat in Pakistan, should be immediately released under the very simple principle of diplomatic immunity". While a respected UK newspaper The Guardian revealed that Davis was a CIA spy on an assignment when he shot dead the two men in Lahore, their claim about his being the acting CIA Station Chief in Pakistan was not correct.
Davis alleges that the then ISI Chief Lieutenant-General Shuja Pasha ensured that the deal for his release was successful, with ISI officials applying pressure to get the families of those killed to accept the "Diyyat". Does one seriously think the DG ISI would ever be personally sitting in a court room to monitor activities? This is blatant effort to give the military a bad name and absolve their political bosses, in particular Zardari and his man in Washington DC talking directly to the US State Department and the CIA, Husain Haqqani. Why do friend Hussain Haqqani and Zardari come out squeaky clean in the Davis narrative? Haqqani was issuing visas to US citizens without due process on the explicit orders of President Asif Zardari? Why did the Foreign Office issue a backdated letter notifying Davis as 'staff member of Islamabad US Embassy on Zardari's orders? Why did Foreign Minister Shah Mehmood Qureshi resign refusing the orders of Asif Zardari to certify Davis as a diplomat? When he was in a Lahore jail, was it not Shahbaz Sharif government's responsibility to provide care and protection? Given the nature of the incident and the CIA being involved, is it strange to have someone from ISI covering the courtroom proceedings? With the Davis affair in the realm of diplomacy and civil administration, how is the military leadership involved in this affair except when asked by the civilian government?
The case illustrates the degree to which the CIA's frontline work has been privatised. Dawn newspaper published invoices on Feb 16, 2011 showing that Davis was paid $780 a day while stationed in Pakistan - and in total was paid $200,000 a year. After Davis left the Army in 2003, he was hired by "Blackwater", along with many other retired personnel. He worked as a mercenary in Iraq on their payroll for the CIA.
Some politicians and some in our security agencies might not be angels; they may have much to answer for, however amidst slurs and falsehood there are too many factual gaps in his book. It is a classic enemy disinformation that targets the Army and the ISI, part of the continuing propaganda campaign against Pakistan and its security agencies. Consider the naiveté of Imran Khan swallowing this bait, "The book is a shameful account of how our top political and military leadership collaborated to let a cold blooded killer, responsible for four deaths go scot-free". With many contradictions the book is a deliberate attempt to defame Pakistani military leadership. The 'memoirs' is probably a RAW-Haqqani joint production conveniently using Davis' name. Davis as the author and Glenn Yeffeth as the Publisher owner of BenBella, Inc are not going to make money publishing the book. Indeed Garson Wright, a Public Relations Company, was hired by "someone unknown" for publicity, this PR Company specializes in "shaping perceptions". From where are the author, the Publisher and the PR Company profiting, indeed even covering their expenses? Indeed what perception were they sharing except maligning the Pakistan Army and the ISI on India's behalf? Davis has been on hard times since he exited Pakistan, being unemployed mostly since 2012, been in several car accidents and even arrested twice. If the book is not going to make money, what is in it for him? His post-Pakistan personal life has been very devastating, even his wife is separated from him.
With Davis blowing the cover of CIA operational network in Pakistan, the huge benefit from his release was the dismantling of almost the entire CIA network and the US Joint Special Operations Command (JSOC). Lieutenant-General Shuja Pasha weeded out the entire supporting network, two CIA Station heads being exposed had to leave Pakistan. Soldiers like Shuja Pasha do not compromise on national interests.
At this particular time the nation is faced with grave external and internal dangers, this is a time for unity, not playing into the hands, of those who wish to harm us. Or is this the latest version of the Dawn Leaks?
(The writer is a security and defence analyst)